Ricotta Nutella Chocolate Cookie Pie

Ricotta Nutella Chocolate Cookie Pie

Ohhhhhhh my. This is just not fair. Be prepared to drool. YOU CAN NOW ORDER THIS PIE FROM OUR STORE!!!!! Moo Milk Bar!!!!!!!! This was the pie seen on Unique Sweets! It is the original version. We have changed it a bit for the shop. But they both taste AMAZING. 

You basically make Marsala sugar cookie dough, push it into a pie dish/tin, fill it with sweetened ricotta and chocolate chips, dump Nutella on the top, pour a shot of Frangelico (I used Disaronno), then cover it with more Marsala sugar cookie dough. Heaven. You may wipe your mouth now.

This recipe made two pies. I had one slice, my boyfriend had another and both of us agreed that we need to get it out of the house immediately. It’s just dangerous. Warning: make this only if you have 16 mouths to feed or if you plan on eating both pies alone in one sitting.

My friend Colette has a Nutella obsession and needed to have some. So a bunch of us gathered together, warmed the pie up, and started to dig in. Friend Jason’s first word was: “Mmm” (with a lot of emphasis on the first “M”). After the pie was done, we talked about Halo-Halo. Four of the seven friends in the room were Filipino.

You’ve been warned…

 IMG_1545 IMG_1527 IMG_1553 IMG_1563 IMG_1573 IMG_1592 IMG_1600 IMG_1609


Ricotta Nutella Chocolate Cookie Pie

Makes 2 pies

For the cookie crust:
2 1/3 cups all-purpose flour
3/4 cup sugar
1 cup butter, room temp cut into pieces 
1 1/2 tsp baking powder
1 egg
1 TBSP milk
1 TBSP Marsala wine

For the filling:
14 oz container of Ricotta
3/4 cup sugar
1 cup chocolate chips
1 shot amaretto (I used Disaronno but you can also use Frangelico)
1/2 cup Nutella (I used more….shhhh)

Preheat oven to 325 deg F

For the cookie crust:
Mix all the ingredients in a stand mixer with a paddle attachment until combined. It will look like really wet sand. When you pinch it between your fingers it should hold together like a dough. While still in the bowl, press it all together with your hands until it forms a ball. 
Turn it out onto your work surface. Knead it just a couple of times to make sure its holding together well. Divide the dough into 2 parts. Set one part aside and divide the other into 2 parts again. Place each those parts into a pie tin/dish and press the dough down and up onto the sides with your hands and fingers. Make sure that it’s pretty much even.

Set in the fridge to rest for 20 minutes. 

For the filling:
In a medium size mixing bowl, combine the ricotta and sugar. Mix/beat well with a rubber spatula until the mixture is smooth. Add the chocolate chips and mix. 
Divide the ricotta mixture evenly between the 2 pies. Drop dollops of the nutella onto the ricotta mixture in the pie. ( 1/4 cup for each pie, but I used a tiny bit more). Try to spread it evenly on top of the ricotta. This was a little hard to do so I kind of swirled it into the ricotta with a knife. Drizzle half a shot of the amaretto onto each pie. 

Take the remaining half of the cookie crust thats resting and break apart small pieces and lay them on top of the filling. This doesn’t have to be pretty. It will look amazing after it’s baked no matter what. 

Bake for 1 hour on the middle rack of the oven. Let rest at least 20-30 minutes. Enjoy this WARM (microwave it 2 days later if you have to). Serve with ice cream =).

12 thoughts on “Ricotta Nutella Chocolate Cookie Pie”

  • How lovely of you to be so kind! I have made all of my family into “White Chocolate Peanut Butter” on toast fans! I am very happy I found your blog and we were partnered for the maiden voyage!

  • Thank you both very much!

    @Melynda – I am very happy to have been partnered up with you! It was a great experience!

  • OK, I’m scared to even make it. I have a slight feeling it may make it’s way into my belly, not out of the house. Sounds ahhhhhmaaaazingly delicious!

  • @Alayna – Woooooooo!!!!!!!! Did you watch Unique Sweets and see the pie being made at Moo Milk Bar? You can also find the recipe on their website. We had changed it a bit for our shop.

  • Pingback: No To Oysters
  • I used to live in the beaches (I’m the one who worked at the tanning salon, journalism student, and would come in for your toffee cookies!!), and I missed this pie SO much! It was a huge hit when I brought it to a family dinner two years ago, and I’ve been looking for a similar recipe ever since I moved back to Sudbury. This is so exciting!

    My Grandpa and I are baking this Sunday, and we’re making a few of the Nutella pies for Christmas.
    So I have two questions: we usually freeze our desserts until Christmas Eve/Day, and I was wondering if we could still to do it with this kind of pie? I’m worried about it getting runny. Also, if we can freeze them, do you have any suggestions to prevent them from getting runny?

    Thanks so much! I miss your toffee cookies and stopping in to say hi! Hope all is well :)

    • Hey Ashley! Sorry for the late response. Thank you for the wonderful compliments! The toffee bit cookies is still my favorite. I don’t recommend freezing this pie unfortunately =( The ricotta doesn’t hold well in the freezer very long. You can make the crust and freeze it and then just quickly whip up the filling with it’s time to bake it. That would all I recommend on making ahead of time. Hope you’re doing well!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *